The outline is Bolton Neighborhood.
Green with Red Star = The rezoning SITE
Gray lots = current multi-family
Purple lots = coming soon multi-family
These are 3 of the 4 lots to be rezoned. (The 4th lot, 1920 Anne St is located behind 1917 La Dawn). 1920 Anne & 1917 La Dawn have been vacant for decades, but at one time there were single family homes on these lots.
1911 & 1905 La Dawn have recently remodeled single family residences. (The developer contends these homes are "falling down" and that is inaccurate.) These homes will be demolished and replaced with 3-story townhomes.
Looking WEST : This is where the trail crosses La Dawn. Nothing but single family homes as far as we can see.
Looking East: More single family homes.
Looking South East: more homes
Looking South West: Another view of the trail crossing & more homes.
Adding excess traffic on La Dawn Ln when there's an alternative option to route traffic to Dunseath Ave via the Anne St right of way - thereby providing more direct access to a major road out of the neighborhood. (without adding additional traffic on La Dawn Ln)
Squeezing 30-40 townhomes into the center of a neighborhood surrounded by single family homes interrupts the character, flow and connectivity of our neighbors.
A townhome community with an HOA is very different from detached single family homes.
Townhomes are being priced at nearly $700,000 which is double the value of neighboring single family homes. This will attract a very different kind of resident to the development and result in gentrification and destruction of the legacy neighborhood and comradery that currently exist.
This will force up property values of neighbors resulting in higher taxes. This will result is pushing fixed/lower income neighbors out of our neighborhood because they wont be able to pay the new taxes.
We already get daily phone calls / letters from speculators/developers who want to buy our properties.
The developer wants to convert Anne Street into a spur to the trail to connect his development to Westside Village (shopping center). He claims this adds value to our neighborhood that residents can use. This spur is not needed. We have side walks in close proximity that more directly connect our neighbors to the shopping center. The sidewalk along La Dawn better serves our neighbors than this spur could. The spur trail would actually be a further distance to walk for our neighbors.
The spur would only benefit the residents of this new development to get to the shopping center; it would be an amenity that the developer can use to market the sale of townhomes and increase prices further.
Anne Street would better add value to our neighbors by serving as the vehicular access point to this property by diverting new/additional traffic off of La Dawn Ln and provide the property with more direct access to Marietta Blvd.
Anne Street is the only access to 1921 Anne Street (different owner). Converting the Anne Street Right of Way to a trail would cut off access to that lot and the lot owner and City will not agree to that.
The development doesn't add any affordable housing which would be a benefit to the community at-large.
We are looking for supporters who are don't want to see our neighborhood lots bought up and assembled into large townhome or apartment complexes.
We have welcomed a number of townhome developments to our neighborhood. Our neighborhood has naturally been transitioning as industrial and warehouse properties become available. These have been located on the peripheral edges of our neighborhood verses the proposed rezoning which wants to convert R-4 single family detached homes into multi-family townhomes.
19 units - Westside Village Townhomes @ 1815-1865 La Dawn Ln
28 units Whetstone Cove @ 2269 Marietta Rd
47 units - Westside Station @ 2003 Marietta Rd
227 units - Altus at the Quarter @ 1130 Ansel Ln
433 units - Liberty Park @ 1260 Liberty Pkwy
= 754 units Townhomes
576 units - BRYKS @ 2200 Marietta Blvd
314 units - Broadstone Upper Westside @ 2167 Bolton Dr
345 units - Luna Upper Westside @ 2265 Marietta Blvd
425 units - Vue at the Quarter @ 2048 Bolton Dr
154 units - Vue 2 @ 2078 Bolton Rd
297 units - Avonlea Westside @ 2788 Defoors Ferry Rd
172 units - Westlight Apartments @ 2453 Coronet Way
112 units - SYNC at West Midtown @ 1391 Collier Rd
= 2,395 units Apartments
41 units - Guild House Apartments @ 2085 Marietta Blvd (townhomes)
349 units - Guild House Apartments @ 2051 Marietta Blvd (flats)
20 units - MiKart @ 1750 Chattahoochee Ave
640 units - MiKart @ 1593 Chattahoochee Ave
214 units - MiKart @ 1661 Chattahoochee Ave
= 1,264 units Coming Soon
==========
= 4,413 units - Total Multifamily
...added this decade, within a 1 mile radius of the proposed townhome site.
The zoning code requires a higher public value. If the claimed benefit (a trail) comes at the cost of displacement, rising property taxes, and loss of legacy neighbors, then the net effect is not public value at all. It is a private value dressed as a public value.
Compatibility with surrounding neighborhoods is a required consideration. Displacement of longtime neighbors on the surrounding streets of Sumter and La Dawn is the most severe form of incompatibility. If the City only measures supposed benefits and not the social and economic costs, then the test of ‘higher public value’ of Derek Turner’s application is incomplete.
Both of the developer's site plans include:
3 story town homes
2,000 sqft each
Increased traffic on La Dawn LN
Egress onto La Dawn Ln
$600,000 price (nearly double that of historic homes)
What's different?
Number of units decreased
Square footage of each unit increased
Zoning request was MR-3 originally, now PD-H
Why did it change?
MR-3 was rejected by both Bolton and NPU-D votes
Amended application to PD-H for a 2nd chance
Neither proposal meshes with the neighborhood